Guide

PERSONAL FINANCE & REAL ESTATE · 5% RULE & NET WORTH

Rent vs. Buy Home Calculator,
5% Rule & true net-worth math.

Compare renting vs. buying a home with the 5% Rule and a full year-by-year net worth simulation. Factor in mortgage interest, property tax, maintenance, closing costs, home appreciation, and invested down-payment opportunity cost.

Scenarios
Home & Mortgage
Rent & Stay Horizon
Taxes, Maintenance & Closing Costs
Tax 1.1% · Maint 1% · Ins $1,800/yr · Rent growth 3%/yr · Closing 3% buy / 6% sell
10-Year Net Worth Verdict
Renting + Investing wins by $67,205
Buyer net worth: $291,489 vs. Renter invested portfolio: $358,694 · Renting stays ahead across all 10 years.
5% Rule Breakeven Rent
$1,875/mo
Your rent ($2,200) is above → favors Buy
Year-1 Buy Cost
$3,213/mo
+$1,013/mo vs. rent
Upfront Cash to Buy
$103,500
Down $90,000 + closing $13,500
Projected Net Worth (Years 1–10)
Buyer Net Worth Renter Portfolio
$0k$179k$359kYr 1Yr 10
Year-1 Monthly Ownership Breakdown
Mortgage Principal & Interest$2,275
Property Tax (1.1%)$413
Maintenance Reserve (1%)$375
Homeowners Insurance & HOA$150
Total Monthly Cost to Buy (vs. $2,200 rent)$3,213
YearHome ValueBuyer Net WorthRenter PortfolioBuy Advantage
Yr 1$465,750$81,829$123,535−$41,706
Yr 2$482,051$101,445$144,598−$43,153
Yr 3$498,923$121,886$166,752−$44,866
Yr 4$516,385$143,188$190,065−$46,877
Yr 5$534,459$165,392$214,609−$49,217
Yr 6$553,165$188,540$240,461−$51,921
Yr 7$572,526$212,676$267,704−$55,029
Yr 8$592,564$237,846$296,427−$58,581
Yr 9$613,304$264,100$326,723−$62,623
Yr 10$634,769$291,489$358,694−$67,205
Educational model · Runs 100% locally in your browser

THE FINANCIAL MODEL

Comparing unrecoverable housing costs and opportunity cost side by side.

1. The 5% Rule Shortcut

Multiply any home’s price by 5% ÷ 12 (for example, $480,000 × 0.05 ÷ 12 = $2,000/mo). If you can rent a comparable property for less, renting and investing the surplus often builds more wealth.

2. Unrecoverable Costs Beyond the Mortgage

Comparing mortgage P&I directly to rent misses property taxes, maintenance (~1%/yr), insurance, HOA fees, and ~9% combined buying/selling closing costs—all modeled explicitly above.

3. Opportunity Cost of Your Down Payment

A 20% down payment plus closing costs is capital that could otherwise compound in a diversified portfolio. Adjusting the Investment Return slider shows how sensitive your break-even year is to market returns.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 5% Rule for renting vs. buying a home?

Popularized by portfolio manager Ben Felix, the 5% Rule estimates the annual unrecoverable cost of owning a home at roughly 5% of its purchase price: ~1% for property taxes, ~1% for ongoing maintenance, and ~3% for the cost of capital (mortgage interest plus the opportunity cost of your down payment). Multiply the home price by 5% and divide by 12—if comparable monthly rent is below that number, renting and investing the difference often wins financially.

Why does the length of time you stay (horizon) matter so much?

Buying and selling a home typically incurs 8% to 10% in combined transaction costs (2%–4% buyer closing costs plus ~6% seller agent/closing fees). Over short stays of 2 to 5 years, those upfront and exit costs usually outweigh home equity growth.

How does the calculator model the renter’s invested portfolio?

The model assumes the renter invests the exact cash they would have spent on the down payment and buying closing costs—plus any monthly cash-flow savings whenever total ownership costs exceed monthly rent—compounding monthly at your chosen investment return rate.

What is included in Total Monthly Ownership Cost?

Beyond mortgage principal and interest (P&I), the calculator includes annual property taxes, a maintenance reserve (default 1% of home value/yr), homeowners insurance, and HOA dues—all of which grow with home value or inflation over time.

Are my financial inputs stored or uploaded?

No. All mortgage amortization, compounding, and net-worth projections run 100% locally in your browser with zero tracking or server uploads.